Octopus Energy vs Home Energy: Which Is Better in 2026?

Our Verdict

Home Energy is the better choice if your main priority is price, while Octopus Energy is the stronger option if you value tariff choice, smart-energy features and an established customer experience.

Octopus Energy and Home Energy are both UK domestic energy suppliers, offering dual fuel and electricity-only tariffs to households across England, Scotland and Wales. The right choice for you depends on what matters most: the cheapest unit rate and standing charge, a wider range of fixed and variable tariff options, faster customer service response times, a higher-rated mobile app, or a greener electricity mix.

If cutting your annual energy bill is the priority, Home Energy’s standard variable tariff currently beats Octopus Energy’s equivalent on price. But if you want more choice — fixed-rate tariffs, time-of-use pricing, EV charging tariffs, or solar and battery export rates — backed by stronger Trustpilot, Citizens Advice and Which? ratings, Octopus Energy is the more complete supplier overall.

Octopus vs Home Energy At a Glance Table

Octopus Energy vs Home Energy — key stats compared at a glance before we break down the full details.

Prices checked: 31 August 2026. Actual costs vary by region, usage, meter type and payment method

If you only wanted to know which supplier is better, you already have the answer above. But if you want to understand why one is better and whether that applies to you, the comparison below breaks down the important differences in simple terms.

Tariffs and Pricing

Both suppliers offer flexible pricing, but their current options differ on cost and price certainty. Here’s how the available tariffs compare.

Octopus Energy

Flexible Octopus is the comparable variable tariff at £1,792 a year. It has no fixed term, although the rates can change. For customers who prefer price certainty, Octopus also offers fixed tariffs; the 12-month fixed option in this comparison costs £1,841 a year and has a £100 exit fee.

Home Energy

Fair Variable Dual is the cheaper variable option in this comparison at £1,625 a year. It has no fixed term and no exit fee, making it around £167 a year (about £14 a month) cheaper than the comparable Octopus variable tariff.

Our Verdict on Pricing

Home Energy wins on variable pricing, with a current saving of around £167 a year based on the comparison figures. However, Octopus Energy has the advantage for customers who want a fixed tariff and the certainty of locked-in rates. Actual costs can vary depending on location, energy use, meter type and payment method.

Tariff Options

Octopus Energy offers a much wider tariff range — including fixed, tracker, and smart options — while Home Energy keeps things simple with a single variable-focused range.

Octopus Energy

Octopus Energy offers a broad mix of variable, fixed and smart tariffs, including options designed for EVs, solar panels, batteries and heat pumps. 

• Flexible Octopus — standard variable tariff; rates can change.
• Fixed tariffs — lock in your rates for a set period.
• Octopus Tracker — prices change daily with wholesale energy costs.
• Agile Octopus — electricity prices change every 30 minutes, suited to households that can shift usage to cheaper periods.
• Intelligent Octopus Go — smart EV tariff with automated charging and six off-peak hours.
• Octopus Go — EV tariff with cheaper overnight electricity.
• Octopus Flux — designed for homes with solar and battery storage.

Home Energy

Home Energy keeps its domestic tariff range much simpler, focusing mainly on variable tariffs with no fixed-term commitment or exit fees. 

• Fair Variable — its main variable tariff for customers paying by Direct Debit.
• Pay on Bill Fair Variable — available for customers who pay when their bill arrives.
• Fixed tariffs — no comparable fixed option identified in the current research.
• Specialist tariffs — no equivalent EV, tracker or solar/battery tariff range identified in the current published domestic offering.

Our Verdict on Tariff Options

Octopus Energy wins. It offers a much broader choice, including fixed, daily and half-hourly pricing plus specialist options for EVs and solar/battery homes. Home Energy is the simpler option if you only want a straightforward variable tariff.

Customer Reviews

Octopus Energy has a much larger, more established review base, while Home Energy’s smaller sample makes a direct comparison harder to draw firm conclusions from.

Octopus Energy

Octopus Energy has a 4.8/5 Trustpilot rating from more than 850,000 reviews, giving it a much larger review base than Home Energy. Customers commonly praise its helpful staff, quick support and straightforward account management, although some reviews mention delays with complex billing or meter issues.

Home Energy

Home Energy currently has a 4.1/5 Trustpilot rating from more than 870 reviews. Recent customers frequently praise its helpful staff, competitive prices and responsive support, while some reviews mention billing delays, refunds and difficulties when leaving the supplier.

Our Verdict on Customer Reviews

Octopus Energy wins. Its higher rating and exceptionally large review base provide stronger evidence of consistently positive customer experiences. Home Energy also receives plenty of positive feedback, but its much smaller review volume makes a direct comparison less conclusive.

App Quality and Features

Octopus Energy’s app is backed by hundreds of thousands of reviews, while Home Energy’s app has fewer than 25 ratings combined — too small a sample to judge reliably.

Octopus Energy

Octopus Energy’s app is highly rated and covers the main account-management tasks, including checking balances, viewing bills and transactions, managing payments and getting support. It is also actively maintained, with the Android app most recently updated on 17 August 2026.

• App Store: 4.8/5 — 251,000 ratings
• Google Play: 4.4/5 — 47,000+ ratings
• Best for: customers who want strong account management and a well-established mobile app.

Home Energy

Home Energy’s app has a much smaller review base, making its ratings harder to compare directly with Octopus. Its lower ratings also suggest there is more room for improvement in the overall app experience.

• App Store: 2.3/5 — 7 ratings
• Google Play: 2.4/5 — 15 ratings
• Best for: customers who mainly need basic account access.

Our Verdict on App Quality

Octopus Energy wins. It has substantially higher ratings, a vastly larger user-review sample and an actively maintained app, making the evidence for its app quality considerably stronger.

Service and Support

Octopus Energy has independently verified Citizens Advice data, while Home Energy relies on its range of contact channels since no comparable Citizens Advice score is currently published for it.

Octopus Energy

Octopus Energy ranks 4th in the latest Citizens Advice customer-service table, with an overall score of 3.67/5. Its published performance includes an average call wait of around 1 minute 17 seconds and 86.1% of emails answered within two days.

• Citizens Advice: #4
• Overall score: 3.67/5
• Average call wait: ~1 min 17 sec
• Emails answered within 2 days: 86.1%

Home Energy

Home Energy does not currently have a comparable Citizens Advice score, so its service performance cannot be directly ranked against Octopus. However, customers can contact its support team through live chat, email, phone and social media, with live-chat support available Monday to Friday, 9am–5pm.

• Citizens Advice: No comparable rating
• Live chat: Yes
• Phone: Yes
• Email: Yes
• Social media: Yes
• Live-chat hours: Mon–Fri, 9am–5pm

Our Verdict on Customer Service

Octopus Energy wins on independently measured service performance, while Home Energy offers several direct support channels but does not have equivalent Citizens Advice data to demonstrate how its service compares.

Complaints and Performance

Octopus Energy publishes detailed quarterly complaint figures, while Home Energy — a smaller, independent supplier — currently has no equivalent data published.

Octopus Energy

In Q1 2026, Octopus Energy recorded 538 complaints per 100,000 customer accounts. It resolved 43% by the same or next working day and 80% within eight weeks. The most common complaints involved customer service, billing and meter readings, payment issues, and smart-meter problems.

Home Energy

Home Energy does not currently publish comparable complaints-performance figures, so there is no like-for-like rate against Octopus. However, its support information provides dedicated channels for customer issues, including live chat, email and phone support.

Our Verdict on Complaints

Octopus Energy has the stronger evidence for complaint performance, simply because it publishes detailed quarterly figures. However, the lack of equivalent Home Energy data does not mean it has more complaints; there is insufficient comparable data to make that claim.

Green Energy Comparison

Octopus Energy supplies a genuinely zero-carbon mix (86.4% renewable, 13.6% nuclear), while Home Energy’s 40.8% renewable share comes alongside gas, nuclear and coal.

Octopus Energy

Octopus Energy focuses heavily on renewable electricity, purchasing power from renewable generators and supporting generation through long-term agreements. It also offers green-energy options linked to solar, batteries and smart tariffs, allowing customers to shift usage towards periods when renewable power is more available.

Home Energy

Home Energy reports that 40.8% of its electricity comes from renewable sources, alongside energy from other generation sources. Its current published information therefore provides a clearer fuel-mix picture than simply describing the tariff as “green”.

Our Verdict on Green Energy

Octopus Energy wins. It offers a stronger renewable-energy proposition, with renewable purchasing, green generation investment and specialist options for homes using solar and battery storage.

Octopus Energy vs Home Energy for EV Owners

If you own an electric car, your energy tariff can make a noticeable difference to your charging costs. Octopus Energy has dedicated EV tariffs, while Home Energy focuses mainly on simple variable tariffs.

Octopus Energy

• Intelligent Octopus Go — smart charging with six hours of low-cost electricity each night.
• Octopus Go — five hours of cheaper overnight electricity and works with all EVs and chargers.
• Smart charging — the app can automatically choose cheaper times to charge your car.
• Home energy benefit — the off-peak rate can also apply to other electricity used in the home.

Home Energy

• No comparable dedicated EV tariff identified in its current published domestic range.
• Customers can still charge an EV using a standard Home Energy tariff, but there is no equivalent specialist smart-charging option currently listed.

Our Verdict for EV Owners

Octopus Energy is the clear winner for EV owners. Its dedicated tariffs, automated charging and cheaper overnight periods give electric-car drivers considerably more flexibility than Home Energy currently offers.

Octopus Energy vs Home Energy for Solar Panels

If you have solar panels, the important question is not only how much electricity you use, but also how much you can earn from the energy you export.

Octopus Energy

Octopus Energy offers several solar export options, including Outgoing Octopus, Outgoing Agile and Octopus Flux for homes with solar and battery storage. Outgoing Octopus currently pays 12p per kWh for exported electricity, while Agile uses half-hourly rates.

• Solar only: Outgoing Octopus
• Solar + battery: Octopus Flux
• Flexible export: Outgoing Octopus
• Dynamic export: Outgoing Agile
• Battery optimisation: Intelligent Octopus Flux

Home Energy

Home Energy does not currently show a comparable range of specialist solar export or solar-and-battery tariffs in its published domestic offering. This means solar customers have fewer dedicated options to compare.

Our Verdict for Solar Customers

Octopus Energy wins clearly for solar homes. Its dedicated export tariffs and solar-and-battery options give customers more ways to use, store and sell their excess electricity.

Which Should You Choose?

Final Verdict

Overall winner: Octopus Energy

Octopus Energy is the better all-round choice if you want more tariff options, a stronger app, established customer-service data and specialist options for EVs and solar. Home Energy is worth considering if keeping your annual energy cost as low as possible is your main priority, with its current variable tariff coming in cheaper in our comparison.

Octopus Energy — Pros & Cons

Pros

• Wide choice of tariffs
• Strong app ratings and a very large review base
• Specialist EV and solar options
• More flexibility for different energy needs

Cons

• Current variable tariff is more expensive than Home Energy
• Some customers still report billing and account issues

Home Energy — Pros & Cons

Pros

• Cheaper variable tariff in this comparison
• Simple tariff choice
• Positive customer feedback on price and support

Cons

• Much smaller independent review sample
• Fewer specialist tariff options
• Less independent performance data available

Bottom line: Choose Home Energy for lower variable pricing; choose Octopus Energy for features, flexibility and a wider range of options.

Compare UK energy suppliers, OVO Energy Vs Utilita Energy  tariffs and deals to find the right option for your home.

Frequently Asked Questions

Common questions about Octopus Energy vs Home Energy — answered.